Back To Blog

On Campus Podcast – The Future of Higher Education: Leading Through Change Without Losing the Mission

Season 4 – Episode 11 – The Future of Higher Education: Leading Through Change Without Losing the Mission

This episode discusses what effective leadership looks like when institutions are being asked to change while remaining grounded in their academic mission.

 

Notes

To view this episode’s notes, simply click on the “More Info” button on the player.


Podcast Chapters

Click to expand/collapse

 

To easily navigate through our podcast, simply click on the ☰ icon on the player. This will take you straight to the chapter timestamps, allowing you to jump to specific segments and enjoy the parts you’re most interested in.

  1. Podcast Introduction and Disclaimer (00:06) Host Ed Butch welcomes listeners to On Campus with CITI Program, introduces the show, and provides an educational disclaimer.
  2. Guest Introduction: Dr. Eric Klein (00:32) Ed introduces Dr. Eric Klein, Vice Provost for Academic Affairs at the American College of Education and author of The Future of Higher Education: Strategic Leadership for Academic Transformation.
  3. Transformational Change vs. Passing Trends (01:02) Dr. Klein explains the evolving relationship between institutions and students, and why AI is a genuinely transformational development.
  4. Leaders as Stewards and Architects (02:57) Discussion on how leaders can protect what is valuable about their institutions while envisioning and preparing for change.
  5. Separating Meaningful Innovation from Trends (04:40) Dr. Klein describes starting with the problem to be solved, experimenting, and evaluating whether innovations make a difference.
  6. Demonstrating the Value of a Degree (06:49) Ed and Dr. Klein discuss transparency around student outcomes and the broader value of higher education beyond a first job.
  7. Changing Student Expectations and Online Education (09:17) Dr. Klein shares how students experience an institution as a whole and what that means for designing the student experience.
  8. Coordination Across Campus Offices (11:35) Ed and Dr. Klein discuss reducing the runaround students face by improving collaboration between offices.
  9. AI and What It Means to Be Educated (12:08) Dr. Klein discusses how AI is prompting institutions to rethink what students need to learn and how learning is assessed.
  10. Faculty Responses to AI and the Future of the Dissertation (14:56) Discussion on how faculty are rethinking assignments, including what the future of the dissertation may look like.
  11. Why Meaningful Change Is Difficult in Higher Education (17:44) Dr. Klein explains the complexity of institutions, differing stakeholder perspectives, and the role of trust and communication in leading change.
  12. Reasons for Optimism About Higher Education (20:12) Dr. Klein shares what gives him confidence in the future of higher education, including the people and the impact institutions have.
  13. Advice for Campus Leaders (22:51) Dr. Klein encourages leaders to make time to think about the future and to involve faculty and staff in those conversations.
  14. Closing Remarks and Credits (25:45) Ed thanks Dr. Klein, invites listeners to visit citiprogram.org, and recognizes the production team.

 


Episode Transcript

Click to expand/collapse

 

Ed Butch: Welcome to On Campus with CITI Program, the podcast where we explore the complexities of the campus experience with higher education experts and researchers. I’m your host, Ed Butch, and I’m thrilled to have you with us today. Before we get started, I want to quickly note that this podcast is for educational purposes only and is not designed to provide legal advice or guidance. In addition, the views expressed in this podcast are solely those of our guests.

Welcome to another episode of On Campus. Today, I want to dig a little deeper into something we have talked about in different episodes on the periphery, but not in depth, the future of higher education. My guest today is Dr. Eric Klein, Vice Provost for Academic Affairs at the American College of Education and author of the forthcoming book, The Future of Higher Education: Strategic Leadership for Academic Transformation. Welcome to the pod, Dr. Klein.

Dr. Eric Klein: Oh, thanks so much for having me. I really appreciate it.

Ed Butch: Of course, of course. So excited to have you and excited to go in depth into this conversation a little bit as well. So I guess to start, when we are looking across higher education right now, I guess what are some of the changes that you think are genuinely transformational as opposed to maybe just some trends that are getting more attention than maybe they deserve?

Dr. Eric Klein: Yeah, thanks. So I think one of the biggest changes I see is the evolving relationship between colleges and universities and the students they serve. And I think that has implications for just about everything we do in higher education. For a long time, institutions largely determined how education would be structured, when the courses would be offered, and what the student experience would look like. Students were generally expected to organize their lives around those expectations, but today we’re seeing that the relationship has evolved in some pretty significant ways. Students are coming to us with different needs, responsibilities and expectations. Many are working adults, their parents, or they’re individuals returning to education after spending years in the workforce, and they want educational experiences that are flexible, relevant, and connected to their goals. Of course, and I’m sure we’ll talk more about this, I think artificial intelligence, AI represents a genuinely transformational development, particularly in how we approach teaching, learning, and assessment.

Where I think we sometimes get distracted is really in our fascination with individual technologies or the latest educational trends. There’s always a new platform, always a new instructional model or innovation that’s generating excitement across the sector. But I think what’s really interesting is how these developments are changing the way people learn and what they expect from higher education. And that’s where I believe the real transformation is taking place and it’s where institutional leaders really need to direct their attention.

Ed Butch: Yeah, definitely. That makes a lot of sense. So you’ve also written about higher education leaders needing to be both stewards and architects. So what do you mean by that and how can leaders preserve what is valuable about their institutions, but also being willing to change?

Dr. Eric Klein: That’s a great question. I appreciate you mentioning my book that’s coming out on December 1st related to the future of higher education, because this is something I’ve really thought about and reflected on throughout my career. So as stewards, we have a responsibility to protect what makes our institutions valuable. That includes academic quality, the institutional mission, and really the trust that students and communities they place in us. At the same time, we also need to think like architects. We have to envision what our institutions can become and help create the conditions that will allow them to thrive in the future. And I really think that’s one of the most interesting challenges of academic leadership. I’ve been really fortunate and privileged to work in several different higher education environments.

And one thing I’ve come to appreciate is that institutional traditions often reflect really deeply held values and a genuine commitment to students. There’s a lot worth preserving there, but circumstances change, students’ needs evolve, and we have to be willing to examine whether our existing structures and practices are still serving their intended purpose. So yeah, I mean, I think our mission, we’ve got to provide continuity, but also direction. And I think effective leaders understand both. They appreciate the institution they’ve inherited, but they also take seriously their obligation to prepare it for the generations of students who will follow.

Ed Butch: Yeah, definitely. Excuse me. It’s a very interesting dichotomy there, and I think that’s a great way to describe it. But going back a little bit, I guess to the trends as well that we hear about and really thinking about it from the terms of innovation, we hear about innovation and universities needing to innovate all the time. So again, how do you think that they can really distinguish between that innovation that is advancing the mission and again, rather than just a trend?

Dr. Eric Klein: Yeah, it’s such an awesome spot-on question. I think the starting point is understanding what problem we’re trying to actually solve. So there’s a lot of pressure on colleges and universities to innovate. I think we understand why the environment’s changing quickly and institutions are rightfully looking for ways to remain relevant and to be responsive. But I think, and I’ve always believed that innovation needs to be connected to a clear purpose. So just for example, if an institution is considering implementing a new, let’s say AI-powered student support system, I’d want to understand what is it we’re hoping to improve? Are students having difficulty getting timely answers? Are advisors managing workloads that make individualized support challenging? Are there opportunities to identify students who may need assistance earlier? And I think once we understand the problem, then we can make a much more informed decision about whether a particular innovation is worth pursuing.

One other thought on this too is I also think we need to become more comfortable experimenting and just learning along the way. So in higher ed, we sometimes invest a lot of time and energy in launching new initiatives and the launch itself becomes a major milestone, but then it’s like what happens afterward? Are students benefiting? Are we seeing improvements in learning and engagement? What have we learned and what might we do differently? So when I think about successful innovation, I think it comes down to understanding the needs of the people we serve and then being willing to evaluate whether our efforts are making a meaningful difference.

Ed Butch: Yeah, I feel like that evaluation part is often, often missed by a lot of offices in programs at universities, definitely. So having worked in student recruitment and retention for 12 years in my previous role, I definitely started to realize that students and families are starting to ask a lot of more difficult questions, including about the value of an undergraduate degree. So what are some ideas that you have that you’ve come across that you think colleges and universities could do to demonstrate the value?

Dr. Eric Klein: Yeah, it’s a great question. And by the way, I think the questions that are being asked, they’re not only fair questions, but they’re questions that higher ed should welcome because for many students and families pursuing a college degree or a graduate degree, it’s one of the most significant investments they’ll ever make, their time, their financial resources, and just the personal sacrifices along the way. So I think students and families, they deserve to understand what is this investment going to mean for their future? And I do think really institutions need to be much more transparent about student outcomes. We should be able to communicate clearly about graduation rates, career opportunities, employment outcomes, and the knowledge and skills that students are developing. I also do believe at the same time that the value of higher ed extends well beyond someone’s first job after graduation. A meaningful college education helps people develop the ability to think critically, communicate effectively, engage with perspectives that are different from their own.

And of course those capabilities, as I’m sure you’ve seen, become even more important. Of course, as technology continues to reshape the workplace and society, but really I think demonstrating value, we have to be clear about the outcomes we’re helping students achieve and we’ve got to take responsibility for delivering an educational experience that supports those outcomes.

Ed Butch: Yeah. As you were saying that, I’m thinking back to my, again, time in recruitment and retention, and a lot of the questions I would get, especially later in my time, would be about those graduation rates and things like that. And I worked under an academic college, I wasn’t even in our office of admissions, and I didn’t even know a lot of those answers to those questions. So I think not only having that, but also getting it to the right people I think is extremely important as well.

Dr. Eric Klein: Absolutely right. Yep.

Ed Butch: So you’ve worked extensively in online education, including your current role, correct?

Dr. Eric Klein: Yes.

Ed Butch: So how do you think the changing student expectations are forcing institutions to rethink the way that education is designed and delivered?

Dr. Eric Klein: Yeah, it’s a great question. I have worked at online institutions like the one I’m working at now. I’ve also worked in campus institutions. I started my career at Lehigh University. I worked for a community college and a community college district for a number of years. And I think one of the things I’ve learned throughout my career is that students experience an institution almost as a whole. So students don’t really think about the distinction between academic affairs, IT, or administrative operations. I think they simply experience how well all the different areas work together to support them. And I think that’s really an important perspective that academic leaders and institutional leaders really need to understand. So students today, as we talked about, they’re balancing education with work, family responsibilities, other commitments, they’re busy, so they need clear communication, accessible support, and they need the ability to engage with their institution in ways that fit their circumstances.

And I think that has huge implications for how we design the student experience. So I mean, actually you referenced my work on online education. I’ve seen how important it is to think really intentionally about everything from course design and faculty engagement to also advising and academic support and just all the administrative processes that students encounter, because really even small frustrations, they can become significant barriers, of course, when students are already managing competing responsibilities. So I think it’s a larger responsibility, and I really encourage everyone, but including leaders, when we look at the educational experience through the eyes of our students, I think then we often discover opportunities to make that experience more accessible, more engaging, and supportive. And it’s really those improvements, even the small incremental ones that could just have a huge impact on students’ ability to achieve their goals.

Ed Butch: Yeah, I think that’s huge, especially the working together, because like you said, it really is. They see it as the large university and them as students. There’s not those segmented offices.

Dr. Eric Klein: Exactly right.

Ed Butch: So instead of getting the runaround, I feel like we give a lot of students a lot of times, because I worked in advising as well, and it’s like, “Oh, well, I’m an advisor, so I can’t answer that, so go over to this office and then go to that office and then go to that office.” Let’s have a little bit more coordination so that they can get an answer ideally in one, maybe two places type of thing.

Dr. Eric Klein: Yeah, that’s exactly right. Yep, spot on.

Ed Butch: All right. Well, you mentioned it earlier, and here we are, we’re getting to it. So AI obviously belongs in this conversation, but I want to look a little bit beyond even the tools themselves. So how do you think that AI is forcing higher ed to reconsider what students actually need to learn and what it means to be educated?

Dr. Eric Klein: Yeah, you’re right. I mean, I think this whole AI thing, it’s prompting us to have some of the most important conversations we’ve had about teaching and learning in a long time. I think that’s a good thing, actually. I just want to think about this. For years, we’ve really emphasized the importance of things like critical thinking, creativity, communication and problem solving. I think AI now is giving us an opportunity, positive reframe, an opportunity to really look at how do we develop and assess those capabilities.

So let’s take writing, for example, or discussion boards in an online environment. If an AI system can generate a reasonably sophisticated essay in seconds, then I think we need to think carefully about what we want students to demonstrate through a writing assignment. What are we interested in? Are we interested in their understanding of the subject? Are we interested in how they evaluate evidence or thinking their capacity to develop an argument and exercise sound judgment? I think these are valuable questions, and they have, as we’re talking about, just major implications for curriculum design, assessment, and faculty development.

So again, I come back to the fundamental purposes I think of generally of higher education. We want students to become independent thinkers who can advocate complexity, that they can exercise good judgment, they can continue learning throughout their lives. And I think one of our biggest responsibilities right now is helping students develop the knowledge and judgment to use AI thoughtfully. They’re going to encounter these technologies throughout their careers, and we have an opportunity to help prepare them for that reality. I think it’s kind of an exciting moment in time. I love thinking more deeply about what an educated person needs to know and be able to do.

I was at a conference last month, it was at Arizona State University. It was about agentic AI and the student experience, and it was basically it was shared there that, listen, virtually everyone, not everyone, but virtually everyone is using AI, including our students, and most of our students are using tools that are not provided by the institution, but are just widely available. So let’s just be candid and real about that and really think thoughtfully about what that means.

Ed Butch: And I’m interested also because obviously you’re working with a lot of faculty in the academic affairs area and things like that. I guess, what are you hearing from them when it comes to the assignments, the writing assignment that you mentioned? Are they thinking differently about their writing assignment? Are they getting rid of writing assignments and moving somewhere else? I guess what does that look like for a lot of faculty?

Dr. Eric Klein: I would say it’s really mixed, and that’s understandable. I will say there are some faculty who are understandably burnt out on, let’s say, the traditional discussion boards where, and now students are just copying and pasting right from their preferred generative AI tool. But like I say, I think the positive reframe is just exploring the opportunity. So even just as a side example, so one of the departments I oversee at American College of Education at ACE is our doctoral research department. And we’ve been talking really, I think thoughtfully about even about what is the future of a dissertation, because right now students can hypothetically generate significant portions of their dissertations, or same could be for master’s theses or undergraduate capstones, whatever it may be, you can use AI to generate. So what does it mean?

And the dissertation as an example, that was always viewed as the ultimate evidence of learning, but maybe going forward, maybe it’s like an in-person oral presentation or it’s a situation like this where we get on a call together and you ask me questions and then I demonstrate my expertise that way. So things are evolving. There’s great questions being asked. We don’t have all the answers or even a lot of the answers, but I come back to, I think for institutional leaders and academic leaders, I think that’s okay. Uncertainty is okay. To have a tolerance for ambiguity I think is a good thing. And I lean optimistic about what the future holds.

Ed Butch: That’s a really interesting example about the dissertation because I’m still, after many years, trying to finish mine. And so the fact that while I’m in this process of so much of this has honestly happened from the start of AI now to where there’s now discussions about completely changing what that dissertation looks like, that’s really interesting. So one thing I’m sure that you do know well is that higher ed, we love our deep established structures and processes, right?

Dr. Eric Klein: We do, yeah.

Ed Butch: So in your opinion, why is meaningful change so difficult in higher ed, even when people agree that change is necessary? Because a lot of what we’re talking about is change that needs to happen, right?

Dr. Eric Klein: Yes. Yeah. I think it’s largely because, and I’m even thinking about some of our most established institutions, they’re just incredibly complex organizations. And by the way, there’s good reasons for a lot of that complexity. I mean, we have academic traditions, we’ve got shared governance, accreditation requirements, financial considerations. There’s a wide range of stakeholders who care deeply about an institution and its future, and all those factors can influence how decisions are made. And by the way, it’s interesting with some of the online institutions or some newer institutions, they’ve got, I guess what I would say, less entanglements in some ways, and so they’re able to pivot and adapt and do things a little bit more easily, I would say, in some cases. But I do think too, like you raised about faculty, and faculty are known to raise concerns about certain things, and very legitimate, by the way.

So faculty, they’re thinking about academic quality and the responsibilities to students. Similarly, administrators, they might be focused on resources and institutional sustainability. Students, of course, as they should be, naturally concerned about how decisions are going to affect their educational experience. So coming back to leadership and part of why I wrote the book, I just think one of the most important responsibilities of leadership is just helping people understand how those different perspectives connect to a shared institutional purpose. And by the way, I’ve also come to appreciate just how trust, I think, how important trust is in the process. So people are more willing to engage in change. I think when they understand the reasons behind it, they feel their perspectives are heard, they have confidence in people leading the effort. So I think what’s required for leaders is consistent communication and a willingness to have difficult conversations.

And sometimes it means acknowledging that a good idea may need to evolve as more people become involved in shaping it. I really do. I just believe deeply in relationships, building a shared understanding, and having the ability to bring people together around a vision that they genuinely believe in.

Ed Butch: Well, as I mentioned, I think a lot of what we’ve brought up here is these challenges maybe leaning a little towards the disruption side of things. So as we wrap up here, last couple of questions, I want to talk a little bit more positive. I guess really what gives you confidence in the future of higher education? What do you think that universities are doing well?

Dr. Eric Klein: Yeah, I’m so glad you asked. It’s part of the reason I wrote the book. I also have something called The Academic Strategist, which is a weekly essay that I do on Substack. And part of the reason is, to be candid with you, I’m actually very optimistic about the future of higher ed. And for me, much of that optimism comes from, I think, the people really that I’ve had the privilege of working with throughout my career. I’ve worked alongside just amazing faculty, academic leaders, student support professionals who are relentless in how they care about students, and then the opportunities education can create. The commitment that these folks have is just remarkable, and I think it’s just one of the greatest strengths of higher education.

And when you think about colleges and universities and what they accomplished, the impact can be extraordinary. I mean, expanding for people, expanding their knowledge, helping them discover new interests, develop their abilities, and perfuse futures they may never have imagined for themselves, let alone what we’re contributing to communities through research, innovation, workforce development, and public service. I just think there’s something really valuable about the role that higher education plays in bringing people into contact with new ideas and different perspectives. And the experience can, I would say, fundamentally change how someone understands the world and their place in it. So I just have a lot of confidence. I mean, part of why I wrote the book too, there’s a lot of negativity right now about certain things.

Ed Butch: There is.

Dr. Eric Klein: Yeah. And I don’t mean to dismiss, there are significant challenges ahead for sure, and institutions need to make some difficult decisions. But having worked in higher ed and worked with amazing people and having attended terrific institutions, I mean, there’s just tremendous talent, creativity, and commitment across the sector. I guess all that to say is I’m excited about what higher education could become. I think with this challenge or these challenges, there’s real opportunity to build on our strengths and also just find new ways to serve students and communities.

Ed Butch: So I guess last question, as we look into the future a little bit, so if you were to give one piece of advice to presidents, provost, and other campus leaders preparing their institutions for the next five years, what would that be?

Dr. Eric Klein: And so I’ll say this with a genuine appreciation for how difficult I know it can be, but I guess I would encourage leaders to be really intentional just about making time to think about the future of their institutions. So like I said, I’ve been really fortunate, blessed. I’ve served in a variety of academic leadership roles. I know how quickly our days can become consumed by immediate challenges, personnel decisions, budget decisions, operational issues. There’s just countless responsibilities that require our attention, and some days we’re just dealing with the immediate needs, and rightfully so.

But I’ve seen where we can become so focused on managing the present that we just don’t have a lot of time or a lot of energy in the tank to really think about, seriously to think about the future. But I do think that’s our responsibility as leaders. We’ve got to be asking some, I would say, fundamental questions about where our schools are headed. What will our students need five years from now? How are expectations around education and employment evolving? What are the new capabilities that our faculty and staff are going to need? And how do we begin preparing our institutions today for those changes? We’ve talked about collaboration and coordination, and I think those conversations need to involve people and leaders from across the organization.

Understandably, truly, I think some of the best, most valuable ideas come certainly from faculty, but also from staff who work directly with students and understand the challenges that they experience every day. And I think that’s one of the central messages in my book, is that the future of our institutions are going to be shaped by the decisions that we make today. I really do believe that the choices we make as leaders, the priorities we establish, the opportunities we create, they’re going to have a long and lasting impact on the students and communities we reserve. So that’s an extraordinary responsibility, but I think it’s also what makes such an exciting time to be working in higher education.

Ed Butch: Yeah. And really, I think you mentioned, and I really appreciate that because I think that’s something unfortunately a lot of leaders I think sometimes forget about is talking with and listening to those staff members that are on the ground with the students and things like that, because not only are the decisions that you’re making today going to affect, but those people are also the future that are going to be promoted up through the ranks at the university and be the leadership down the road as well.

Dr. Eric Klein: Yeah, you’re absolutely right.

Ed Butch: Well, thank you so much, Dr. Klein. I really appreciate your time. I appreciate your optimism, because I don’t hear a lot of that around higher ed nowadays, so I do appreciate that. So thank you so much for your time.

Dr. Eric Klein: I appreciate it. Let’s stay optimistic. Thanks, everyone.

Ed Butch: I invite all of our listeners to visit citiprogram.org to learn more about our courses and webinars on research, ethics, compliance, and higher education. I look forward to bringing you more expert guests to discuss what’s happening on campus. Special thanks to our line producer, Evelyn Fornell. Production and distribution support provided by Raymond Longaray and Megan Stuart.

 


How to Listen and Subscribe to the Podcast

You can find On Campus with CITI Program available from several of the most popular podcast services. Subscribe on your favorite platform to receive updates when episodes are newly released. You can also subscribe to this podcast, by pasting “https://feeds.buzzsprout.com/1896915.rss” into your your podcast apps.

apple podcast logo

spotify podcast logo

amazon podcast logo


Recent Episodes

 


Meet the Guest

Content Contributor Eric Klein

Eric Klein, PhD – American College of Education

Eric Klein, PhD, is Vice Provost for Academic Affairs at American College of Education and author of The Future of Higher Education: Strategic Leadership for Academic Transformation. An experienced academic leader, he holds a PhD from Fairleigh Dickinson University and an Executive Certificate in Higher Education Leadership from Harvard University.


Meet the Host

Team Member Ed Butch

Ed Butch, Host, On Campus Podcast – CITI Program

Ed Butch is the host of the CITI Program’s higher education podcast and the Associate Director of Higher & Secondary Education at CITI Program. He focuses on developing content related to higher education policy, compliance, research, and student affairs.